What are the pros and cons of free post-secondary education?
12 comments Posted onI was reading Chitown’s blog Windy City Blues today through my RSS feed, and she was talking about what her financial plan was now that she’s done law school. I got to about the point in her post where she mentioned her student loan debt: $207k. Holy crap!!! It makes my $17k of debt look so small next to that amount … but perhaps it’s all relative to the careers that we have. Obviously she’ll make a lot more money than me since she went to law school, and all I have is a half-finished marketing degree and a college diploma in communications.
It makes me envious of other countries that offer free post-secondary education like France and Germany (I think). But I was reading up a little on government-run Universities, and apparently people think that the level of education offered there is lower than what you would find at a private institution. Also, an old teammate of mine told me that becoming a doctor is a lot easier in some countries in Europe because you don’t need to take all the fluff general classes – you just go straight into the classes you’ll actually need, and apparently that drastically reduces the amount of time spent in school. By years.
Anyway, I honestly don’t know much about the pros and cons of free post-secondary education, or really even on how other countries run their educational system, and I couldn’t find very helpful articles on the internet about it. Then again, I didn’t really look that hard. I wonder if anyone out there knows of a website that explains the pros and cons?
Labels: education
I am not a University graduate. I have 2 1/2 yrs. completed towards a B.A.A. in Sports Marketing (double-minors in journalism & athletic coaching) from Central Michigan University. I was on a full athletic scholarship to play field hockey at an NCAA Div.1 school, but I left after my sophomore year. I guess I was homesick and burnt out from training so intensely for so many years. Looking back, it wasn't anything I couldn't suck up for another 2 years ... but back then, quitting and going home seemed like a matter of life or death. I was such an idiot!
And I can't go back there and finish up my degree because I refuse to play elite level sports again. I still play field hockey 3 or 4 times a week, and I still go to the gym almost every day, but I don't obsessively train for 5-6 hrs a day like I used to (in the summer it was 8 hrs/day!!!). I think that might kill me! Anyway, to go back to CMU without a scholarship, as an international student, it would cost me $36,000 for tuition and board alone.
Of course, it's easy to reflect on how stupid I was, now that I've taken myself far away from that situation. And it's not like I fully regret quitting, because I wouldn't be where I am today if I had stayed ... but I'm upset that I had a FULL SCHOLARSHIP (i.e. free money), and passed it up because I believed I was too tired to train, and too homesick to continue.
I have a college diploma hanging up on the wall behind me from a 2-year program I graduated from last year. At least that's something. And it's transferable, so I only have to take 2 more years to earn my B.A. in Communication Studies. That was the plan. I have an acceptance letter from Athabasca University's distance education program sitting in a folder at home, and I had every intention of taking classes as soon as I gained full-time employment after college. So a year later, why haven't I taken a single class?
The big barrier is money. Isn't that always the case? :) Other priorities came up for me, namely paying off my student loans. And now, saving up for a down payment on a condo. It's approximately $650 for each class through Athabasca, all distance-ed, so I could still continue to work full-time. I need 20 classes. $650 x 20 = $13,000.
I really really REALLY don't want to take out student loans again if I don't have to. So is it worth it? Is it worth $13,000 for a university degree? Is it really going to help me out in the job force?
The job I have now required a university degree and 3 years of experience - I have neither and got the job. So can experience outweigh education? Or was it just a fluke that I got hired here? In the future, are my resumes going to be tossed out as soon as they're received because I don't fit the educational mold they're after?
If an employer is looking for someone with a degree, and all I have is a diploma and a bunch of experience, is that employer going to pick the person with the degree and little to no experience? Because if that's the case, I don't want to get screwed over, and I'll go get that degree. But if it's just a matter of digging a little more and applying to more places before an employer decides to considers me, then maybe it's not worth it. What do you think?
Labels: education



